Recent Experience
Deal Counsel to GE in Sale of Business
Acquisition of Sistersville Bancorp, Inc., the Parent of First Federal Savings Bank, by Peoples Bancorp., Inc, the Parent of Peoples Bank, Through a Merger of the Two Parent Companies
Manage Contract and General Service Agreement Process for Furniture Distributor
Search Experience
Services
Acquisitions & Dispositions
Affirmative Action Plans/OFCCP Compliance
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Americans With Disabilities Act
Antitrust & Trade Regulation
Appellate
Appellate Practice - Employment
Arbitrations
Audits, Counseling & Training
Bankruptcy & Restructuring
Class Action
Collective Bargaining Negotiations
Commercial Finance
Compensation & Benefits
Corporate & Transactional
Development & Zoning
Economic Incentives & Finance
Eminent Domain & Valuation
Employment
Employment Discrimination Litigation
Employment, Labor & Benefits
Environmental
ERISA Litigation & Administrative Proceedings
ESOPs
Estate & Trust
Estate Administration
Estate Planning
Executive Compensation
Family Law
Federal Income Tax
Finance
Financial Institutions Compliance
First Amendment & Media
Franchise and Distribution
Government Investigations
Government Relations
Health & Welfare Benefits
Immigration
Intellectual Property
International Business
International Tax
Internet & E-Commerce
Investment Advisers
Labor
Leasing & Property Management
Licensing & Technology Transfer
Litigation
Mass Tort
Mergers & Acquisitions
Mine Safety & Health Administration
NLRB Issues
Non-Competition Litigation
Nonprofit Organizations
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
Patent Litigation
Patent Prosecution
Personal Tax Planning
Private Placements
Products Liability
Public Company Compliance & Governance
Public Finance
Public Offerings
Real Estate
Regulatory
Retirement Plan Documents
RICO Actions
Securities
Shale Resources
State & Local Tax
Strike Preparation/Litigation
Taxation
Tort
Toxic Tort
Trademarks
Venture Capital
Wage/Hour Law
White Collar Crime
Workers' Compensation
Workplace Safety
Worksite Compliance
Wrongful Discharge
Industries
Banking & Financial Services
Construction
Education
Entertainment, Media & Sports
Equine & Gaming
Health Care
Insurance
Motor Vehicle & Motorcycles
Municipal & Government
Natural Resources
Pharmaceutical & Medical Devices
Public Utilities
A
|
B
|
C
|
D
|
E
|
F
|
G
|
H
|
I
|
J
|
K
|
L
|
M
|
N
|
O
|
P
|
Q
|
R
|
S
|
T
|
U
|
V
|
W
|
X
|
Y
|
Z
Select Office
Charleston, WV
Cincinnati, OH
Columbus, OH
Dayton, OH
Frankfort, KY
Lexington, KY
Louisville, KY
Morgantown, WV
Pittsburgh, PA
Washington, D.C.
Wheeling, WV
Lewisburg, WV
Philadelphia, PA
Services
Acquisitions & Dispositions
Affirmative Action Plans/OFCCP Compliance
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Americans With Disabilities Act
Antitrust & Trade Regulation
Appellate
Appellate Practice - Employment
Arbitrations
Audits, Counseling & Training
Bankruptcy & Restructuring
Class Action
Collective Bargaining Negotiations
Commercial Finance
Compensation & Benefits
Corporate & Transactional
Development & Zoning
Economic Incentives & Finance
Eminent Domain & Valuation
Employment
Employment Discrimination Litigation
Employment, Labor & Benefits
Environmental
ERISA Litigation & Administrative Proceedings
ESOPs
Estate & Trust
Estate Administration
Estate Planning
Executive Compensation
Family Law
Federal Income Tax
Finance
Financial Institutions Compliance
First Amendment & Media
Franchise and Distribution
Government Investigations
Government Relations
Health & Welfare Benefits
Immigration
Intellectual Property
International Business
International Tax
Internet & E-Commerce
Investment Advisers
Labor
Leasing & Property Management
Licensing & Technology Transfer
Litigation
Mass Tort
Mergers & Acquisitions
Mine Safety & Health Administration
NLRB Issues
Non-Competition Litigation
Nonprofit Organizations
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
Patent Litigation
Patent Prosecution
Personal Tax Planning
Private Placements
Products Liability
Public Company Compliance & Governance
Public Finance
Public Offerings
Real Estate
Regulatory
Retirement Plan Documents
RICO Actions
Securities
Shale Resources
State & Local Tax
Strike Preparation/Litigation
Taxation
Tort
Toxic Tort
Trademarks
Venture Capital
Wage/Hour Law
White Collar Crime
Workers' Compensation
Workplace Safety
Worksite Compliance
Wrongful Discharge
Industries
Banking & Financial Services
Construction
Education
Entertainment, Media & Sports
Equine & Gaming
Health Care
Insurance
Motor Vehicle & Motorcycles
Municipal & Government
Natural Resources
Pharmaceutical & Medical Devices
Public Utilities
Corporate & Transactional
Employment, Labor & Benefits
Intellectual Property
Litigation
Regulatory
Industries
Ancillary Services
Bankruptcy & Restructuring
Estate & Trust
Finance
Franchise and Distribution
Government Relations
International Business
Mergers & Acquisitions
Real Estate
Securities
Taxation
Audits, Counseling & Training
Compensation & Benefits
Employment
Immigration
Labor
Workplace Safety
Internet & E-Commerce
Licensing & Technology Transfer
Patent Litigation
Patent Prosecution
Trademarks
Alternative Dispute Resolution
Appellate
Class Action
First Amendment & Media
Products Liability
Tort
White Collar Crime
Workers' Compensation
Antitrust & Trade Regulation
Environmental
Financial Institutions Compliance
Government Investigations
Banking & Financial Services
Construction
Education
Entertainment, Media & Sports
Equine & Gaming
Health Care
Insurance
Motor Vehicle & Motorcycles
Municipal & Government
Natural Resources
Pharmaceutical & Medical Devices
Public Utilities
Mercantile Title
Estate Administration
Estate Planning
Family Law
Commercial Finance
Public Finance
Venture Capital
Acquisitions & Dispositions
Development & Zoning
Economic Incentives & Finance
Eminent Domain & Valuation
Leasing & Property Management
Investment Advisers
Private Placements
Public Company Compliance & Governance
Public Offerings
Federal Income Tax
International Tax
Nonprofit Organizations
Personal Tax Planning
State & Local Tax
ERISA Litigation & Administrative Proceedings
ESOPs
Executive Compensation
Health & Welfare Benefits
Retirement Plan Documents
Affirmative Action Plans/OFCCP Compliance
Appellate Practice - Employment
Employment Discrimination Litigation
Non-Competition Litigation
Wage/Hour Law
Wrongful Discharge
Worksite Compliance
Arbitrations
Collective Bargaining Negotiations
NLRB Issues
RICO Actions
Strike Preparation/Litigation
Mine Safety & Health Administration
Occupational Safety & Health Administration
Mass Tort
Toxic Tort
Shale Resources
Accomplish More
History
Firm Facts
Diversity
Recognitions
Legal Networks
Community
Media organizes all that's new at the Firm - legal commentary, announcements, publications and events. To search this section, enter a keyword or select the type of information that interests you.
Publications
News
Events
Charleston, WV
Cincinnati, OH
Columbus, OH
Dayton, OH
Frankfort, KY
Lewisburg, WV
Lexington, KY
Louisville, KY
Morgantown, WV
Philadelphia, PA
Pittsburgh, PA
Washington, D.C.
Wheeling, WV
Related Attorneys
April L. Besl
Related Services
Intellectual Property
Trademarks
Related Industries
Entertainment, Media & Sports
Publications
News
Events
The Fate of the Music Industry is Jeopardized by Copyright Decision
Decision Impacts Billions of Dollars in Royalties
July 23, 2012
April Besl
A recent decision out of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit could have lasting implications on all Copyright Royalty Board rate determinations since 2004. In the case
Intercollegiate Broadcasting System, Inc. v. Copyright Royalty Board
, a unanimous panel at the D.C. Circuit found that the structure of the Royalty Board was unconstitutional under the Appointments Clause.
Intercollegiate Broadcasting is an association of “noncommercial” webcasters offering transmission of digitally recorded music over the internet at high schools and college campuses. These broadcasts constitute “performances” under the Copyright Act and thus require royalty payment to the song owners. When parties cannot agree upon the license terms, they can go before the Royalty Board for a determination of a fair royalty rate. Established in 2004, the Royalty Board is composed of three judges appointed to six-year terms by the Librarian of Congress.
After being unable to come to terms as to a royalty rate with a non-profit clearinghouse for musicians called Soundexchange, Inc., the parties took their dispute before the Royalty Board who issued a final determination setting a rate Intercollegiate would have to pay. Intercollegiate appealed the decision to the D.C. Circuit arguing, among other things, the unconstitutionality of the Royalty Board’s structure under the Appointments Clause.
Specifically, Intercollegiate argued that the Copyright Royalty Judges (“CRJs”) exercise significant ratemaking authority, without any effective means of control by a superior which qualified them as a “principal” officer under the Appointments Clause. All “principal” officers must be appointed by the President with Senate confirmation, which made the appointment of the CRJs unconstitutional.
The D.C. Circuit agreed, first finding that CRJ decisions can have considerable consequences that can affect the fates of entire industries and implicate billions of dollars in royalties. The panel also noted that CRJ decisions not only impact traditional forms of music media (e.g. CDs and vinyl) but also emerging technologies including digital downloads, non-commercial broadcasting, and certain cable transmissions. In light of the significant authority, the fact that the Librarian of Congress could not affect decisions of the CRJ’s or even remove them from office made them “principal” officers under the Appointments Clause.
Rather than wait for Congress to act, the D.C. Circuit chose to nullify language from the Copyright Act that originally had barred the Librarian from removing the Judges from office, thus making them “inferior” officers. In so doing, the D.C. Circuit held that the rate determination of the CRJs for Intercollegiate was vacated due to the unconstitutional nature of the Royalty Board’s structure.
Whether or not this has opened the door for entities to challenge rate decisions made by the Royalty Board as invalid since 2004 is still up for debate but copyright owners and broadcasters should certainly be prepared for a potential fight in the near future.