Inoperability Alone Does Not Defeat Motivation to Combine

In a significant motivation-to-combine decision regarding obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103, the Federal Circuit in In re NETLIST, Inc. 2025-1286, 2025-1296 affirmed the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) determinations that claims of Netlist’s U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215 were obvious over a combination of U.S. Patent No. 7,363,422 (Perego) and the JEDEC DDR2 SDRAM standard (JESD79-2). Importantly, the Federal Circuit rejected Netlist arguments that a skilled artisan would not have made the proposed combination because doing so would render Perego’s Rambus-based architecture inoperable for its intended purpose, including the loss of Rambus compatibility and related backward-compatibility benefits. The Federal Circuit explained the limited role that “inoperability” plays in the motivation-to-combine analysis.

Key Takeaways

  • Prior art can be repurposed beyond its original design objective: familiar items may have obvious uses beyond their primary purposes, and a skilled artisan may combine references in ways that depart from the original goals of the prior art.
  • Inoperability is a narrow exception: A showing that a modification would render the prior art inoperable for its original intended purpose does not, by itself, negate motivation to combine.
  • Two recognized circumstances may give an inoperability argument force: First, the motivation to combine is drawn from the prior art and the proposed modification effectively teaches away from the combination because it defeats the very functionality that motivates the modification. Second, the modification destroys a purpose shared by both the prior-art reference and the challenged claims.

Motivation to Combine: Focus on the Claimed Invention, Not the Prior Art’s Original Purpose

At issue was whether a skill artisan would have been motivated to combine Perego with JESD79-2 to arrive at the claimed invention. At the relevant time, two industry-standard memory architectures existed: the JEDEC architecture and the Rambus architecture.[i] Perego was directed to a Rambus-based system. According to Netlist, incorporating teachings from JESD79-2, a JEDEC standard, would fundamentally transform Perego’s architecture from a Rambus system into a JEDEC system, thereby eliminating the very functionality for which Perego was designed.[ii] On that basis, Netlist argued that the proposed combination lacked a motivation to combine because it “would make Perego’s system non-functional for Rambus.”[iii] Thus, the two patents at issue should be considered non-obviousness.

The Federal Circuit rejected that argument and reaffirmed the flexible obviousness framework articulated in KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007). Quoting KSR, the Federal Circuit emphasized that “familiar items may have obvious uses beyond their primary purposes, and in many cases a person of ordinary skill will be able to fit the teachings of multiple patents together like pieces of a puzzle,” and “[t]he inquiry is not whether a relevant artisan would combine a first reference’s feature with a second reference’s feature to meet requirements of the first reference that are not requirements of the claims at issue”[iv]  Under KSR framework, the fact that a modification may impair a prior-art embodiment does not necessarily undermine a motivation to combine if the modification would help achieve the claimed invention.

The Limited Role of Inoperability Arguments

The Federal Circuit clarified that rendering a prior-art reference inoperable for its intended purpose does not, standing alone, demonstrate non-obviousness. Rather, the court explained that there are only “limited circumstances where the purpose of the prior art device is pertinent” to the motivation-to-combine inquiry.[v]

Teach Away

One such circumstance arises when the motivation to combine is drawn from the prior art, and the proposed modification would effectively cause the prior art to teach away from the combination because it defeats the very functionality that provides the reason for making the modification in the first place.[vi] For example, in In re Gordon, 733 F.2d 900 (Fed. Cir. 1984), the claimed invention was directed to a blood-filter assembly having the inlet and outlet at the bottom of the device, while the prior-art reference disclosed a gasoline filter with the inlet and outlet positioned at the top. Because the prior-art filter relied on gravity to separate contaminants from gasoline, relocating the ports would have defeated the operating principle of the reference itself. The Gordon court therefore concluded that the proposed modification would render the prior-art device inoperable for its intended purpose and that the reference effectively taught away from the modification.

Shared Purpose

A second circumstance arises when the proposed modification eliminates a purpose that is shared by both the prior-art reference and the challenged claims.[vii] In that situation, the modification does more than merely impair a feature unique to the prior art; it undermines an objective that is central to the claimed invention itself. Because the proposed modifications frustrated a goal common to both the prior art and the claimed invention, they undermined the asserted rationale for combining the references.

Applying these principles, the Federal Circuit concluded that Netlist’s argument improperly focused on preserving Perego’s Rambus compatibility. The court observed that the Petitioners did not rely on Perego’s Rambus capabilities to establish motivation to combine, or Perego’s backward-looking compatibility with Rambus to support a motivation to combine,[viii] and Netlist did not contend that Perego taught away from the chip-select signaling disclosed in JESD79-2. [ix] Instead, Netlist’s position was only that incorporating the JEDEC-based teachings would render Perego’s Rambus implementation nonfunctional.[x] The court found that argument insufficient because Rambus compatibility was a feature of Perego, not a requirement of the challenged claims. [xi]

The Federal Circuit also rejected Netlist’s contention that the petitioners and the PTAB failed to articulate any independent motivation to combine Perego with JESD79-2.[xii] According to the court, the PTAB identified multiple reasons why a person of ordinary skill would have been motivated to combine the references, and those findings were supported by substantial evidence.

For more information regarding this case, and obviousness type rejection strategies, please contact the author of this article.


[i] In re NETLIST, Inc. 2025-1286, 2025-1296, p. 2.

[ii] Id., p. 5-7

[iii] Id., p. 7

[iv] Id., p. 9, (citing KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398, 420 (2007)).

[v] Id., p. 10

[vi] Id., p. 10-11.

[vii] Id., p. 11-12.

[viii] Id., pp. 10-11.

[ix] Id., p. 8.

[x] Id., p. 6

[xi] Id., pp. 9, 12

[xii] Id., pp. 13-14.