Joseph N. Tucker

Experience

Dinsmore Obtains Summary Judgment for Horse Registry Association

Client: Horse Registry Non-Profit Association

A horse registry association was sued by one of its members related to the proper registration of a horse.  After 18 months of litigation, Dinsmore obtained summary judgment and a six-figure attorneys’ fee award for its client association.

Dinsmore Obtains Dismissal for Prominent Show Jumper Trainer

Client: Prominent Show Jumper Trainer

A well-respected horse trainer in south Florida sold a sport horse. The buyer claimed the horse had an undisclosed condition resulting in the failure to perform for the intended use.  After minimal discovery and motion practice, Dinsmore obtained dismissal of the lawsuit for its client.

Defects Found in Horse Show Footing

Client: Nationally Known Horse Show Facility

Litigation counsel for licensed competition after defects were found in newly installed horse show footing.  After filing suit and establishing defects in the construction through documentary evidence and expert testimony, the matter was settled favorably for Dinsmore’s client.  

Allegations of Breach of Insurance Contract

We represented an insurance company in a suit for breach of insurance contract and bad faith arising out of insurance company’s decision not to pay benefits under an occupational accident insurance policy. The case was removed to federal court and summary judgment was granted in favor of the insurance company.

Allegations of Breach of Insurance Contract and Bad Faith

We represented an insurance company in a suit for breach of insurance contract and bad faith arising out of the client’s decision not to pay benefits under an automobile accident insurance policy. The case was removed to federal court and eventually settled at mediation.

Allegations of Breach of Insurance Contract and Bad Faith

We represented a company in a matter where the insurance company refused to defend or indemnify our client in a third-party law-suit arising out of our client’s business operations. We brought claims in federal court for breach of insurance contract and bad faith. The case was resolved prior to mediation for all possible damages awardable under the insurance contract, including attorneys’ fee, costs and interest.

Alleged Violations of Fair Debt Credit Protection Act

We represented a debt purchaser when a consumer brought a class action counterclaim against the client for alleged violations of the FDCPA and Kentucky usury laws. The consumer argued that the National Bank Act did not preempt Kentucky usury laws and that the Dodd-Frank Act no longer allowed federal preemption to assignees. Summary Judgment was granted to debt buyer.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. Cereal Manufacturer

We represented the Defendant's insurer in a suit for $10,000 against a cereal manufacturer for Plaintiff's broken tooth due to an alleged foreign object in the cereal.  The case was settled prior to mediation.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed suit against our client, a general contractor, seeking $100,000 for defects in Plaintiff's home related to the use of synthetic stucco (EIFS) material.  Dinsmore & Shohl obtained a dismissal in favor of the general contractor on the basis of the North Carolina Statute of Repose.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed suit against our client, general contractor, seeking $1 million for defects in Plaintiff's home related to the use of synthetic stucco (EIFS) material.  Dinsmore & Shohl negotiated settlement with the homeowners on the general contractor's behalf and prosecuted third-party claims against the EIFS product manufacturer.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiffs filed a $300,000 suit against our client, the general contractor, for defects in Plaintiff's home related to moisture intrusion and structural defects.  The general contractor in turned filed suit against 12 different subcontractors.  The case was settled favorably for the client after two days of mediation.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed suit against our client, a general contractor, seeking $1,000,000 for defects in Plaintiffs' home related to the use of synthetic stucco (EIFS) material.  Dinsmore & Shohl obtained dismissal in favor of the general contractor, individually, which was affirmed on appeal.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed a $300,000 suit against our client, the general contractor, for defects in Plaintiff's home.  The claim went through arbitration, settling favorably for the client after a minimal verdict was rendered.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed suit for $1,000,000 against our client, the general contractor, for defects in Plaintiff's home. The claim went through a week-long arbitration, settling favorably for the client before a verdict was rendered.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. General Contractor

Plaintiff filed suit for $300,000 against our client, the general contractor, for defects in Plaintiff's home.  The claim went through three days of arbitration, settling favorably for the client after a minimal verdict was rendered.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. Insurance Company

Plaintiff filed a class action lawsuit against our client, an insurance company, seeking coverage in excess of $75,000 for moisture intrusion damage due to defects in Plaintiff's home.  The case was removed to Federal court, was never certified as a class action and was eventually dismissed.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. Owners of Nursing Home

The Plaintff sued our client, the owner of a nursing home, for $100,000 for negligence related to a slip and fall.  The claim was dismissed on summary judgment.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. Plastics Manufacturer

Plaintiff sued our client, a plastics manufacturer, for personal injury and product liability when a chair manufactured by the client broke.  The case was settled at mediation.

Anonymous Plaintiff v. Smoke Alarm Manufacturer

Plaintiff filed suit against our client, a smoke alarm manufacturer, seeking $1 million for the wrongful death of a university student killed in an off-campus apartment fire.  Plaintiff ultimately dismissed the suit with prejudice and no settlement payment was made.

Anonymous Plaintiffs v. Securities Company

Our firm represented the Plaintiffs in two separate suits for fraud, each in the amount of $1,000,000, against a securities company related to investment in a start-up company.  Both cases were settled favorably prior to arbitration.

Anonymous Plaintiffs v. Vacation Resort

Plaintiffs were injured while on vacation at a resort in Mexico.  They sued our client, the Florida company responsible for the resort's marketing and sales.  Plaintiffs claims were dismissed for lack of in personam jurisdiction.

Anonymous Plaintiffs v. Window Manufacturer

Plaintiffs filed a $200,000 suit against the general contractor, who in turn filed suit against our client, a window manufacturer, for alleged defects in the windows.  The case was settled after mediation.

Anonymous Plaintiffs v. Window Manufacturer

Plaintiffs sued our client, a window manufacturer, for $75,000 for allegedly defective windows.  The case was settled.

Breach of Contract and Tort Claims Against Insurance Benefits Company

An insurance benefits company acquired the assets of another company operating as third-party administrator. Shortly after acquisition, the third-party administrator was sued, along with the insurance benefits company for various breach of contract and tort claims. The matters at issue include successor liability, enforceability of arbitration clause and indemnification and indemnity claims.

Cable Television Company v. Owner of Nursing Home

A cable television company sued our client, the owner of a nursing home, for $500,000 for utilizing the cable company's interior wiring for the nursing home's own use.  The parties settled after protracted litigation.

Homeowner v. General Contractor and Siding Manufacturer

We represented the Plaintiff homeowner in a suit for $200,000 against the general contractor and siding manufacturer for damages to the client's home.  The case was settled at mediation.

Hotel Owners v. Painting Subcontractor

Plaintiff hotel owners filed a $300,000 suit against our client, a painting and moisture proofing subcontractor, and against the coating manufacturer for moisture damage to the hotel.  The claim settled favorably for the client after mediation and before trial.

Industrial Contractor v. Various Subcontractor Defendants

Our client, an industrial contractor and supplier, sued the subcontractor for non-payment of $75,000.  The case was settled before litigation was filed.

Insurance Coverage Dispute Involving Allegations of Bad Faith

We represented an insurance company in a suit for breach of insurance contract and bad faith arising out of the client’s decision not to pay death benefits under an occupational accident insurance policy. The case was removed to federal court and summary judgment was granted in favor of the insurance company.

Insurance Coverage Dispute Involving Allegations of Bad Faith, Breach of Contract

We represented an insurance company in a suit for breach of insurance contract and bad faith arising out of the client’s decision not to pay disability benefits under an occupational accident insurance policy. The case was removed to federal court and the matter was resolved at mediation.