Dinsmore Courtroom Win Paves the Way for WV Helping Hands Housing Project

Litigator Jennifer K. Mason led the team that secured a mandamus and court-ordered building permit, unlocking $11 million in funding for family housing in Ronceverte, West Virginia

Dinsmore secured a significant win for WV Helping Hands, a West Virginia nonprofit, when a Greenbrier County judge ordered the City of Ronceverte to issue a building permit for the organization’s long-planned housing project. Lewisburg-based litigation partner Jennifer K. Mason led the Dinsmore team, which included associates Lauren Motes (Morgantown, W.Va.), Billy Devericks (Huntington, W.Va.), Jared Phalen and senior associate Sean D. Thomas (Charleston, W.Va.).

The ruling allows Helping Hands to move forward with turning a vacant former hospital on Greenbrier Avenue into apartments for local families working toward stability. Residents will sign one-year renewable leases and have access to on-site day care, vocational training, and job placement help. The decision also frees up an $11 million grant awarded for the project but held back until the permit was approved.

“Today’s ruling clears the road for WV Helping Hands to break ground in Ronceverte. There has been a misunderstanding about our plans: this is not a shelter. It is a path forward that helps individuals and families navigate toward stability, with a one-year renewable lease, their own apartment, day care, and vocational training with job placement support,” said WV Helping Hands Chair Amy Hubbard. “Jennifer Mason and her team at Dinsmore cleared the way, and we look forward to working with the City of Ronceverte to serve 25 families initially, and up to 42 over time.”

WV Helping Hands has been working toward the project since 2021. As plans moved forward, the city passed a 2023 rule requiring special approval for homeless shelters and treated the project as one. The nonprofit’s permit application then sat for more than a year without an answer, so WV Helping Hands turned to Dinsmore.

Jennifer and the team asked the court for a writ of mandamus, which is an order telling the government to do something the law requires it to do. The Dinsmore legal team had to prove that WV Helping Hands is clearly entitled to what they want, that the government clearly has to provide it, and that there’s no other way to get it.

In an order entered Nov. 12, the Court granted the request. The judge found that the city didn’t follow the proper steps when it passed the rule, and that the rule wouldn’t apply anyway, because the project is housing, not a shelter. The judge also agreed that under state law, the permit was automatically approved when the city didn’t respond within 60 days.

Local station Fox59 (WVNS-TV) interviewed Amy and Jennifer for a 59 News segment. Watch here.